my name is not matt | random musings of an aspiring photographer

May/09

20

funny take on the pc/mac debate

          

           Please note: the video has a couple of “adult words.” (very briefly @ 3:32 mark)

 

I love it! There are some great anologies in the video.

OK, forgive me, but I’m still on this topic. PC vs. Mac. Putting aside my seemingly never-ending problem with Windows Explorer not responding, I have turned to doing what I do best — researching the hell out of something before making a decision.  At the most basic level, I have the same reaction to Macs that I suspect most other people do. Ooooooh…ahhhh. It’s hard to look at, or put your hands on, a Mac without having some sense of technological or aesthetic arousal. They are sexy.  However, just as I am with people, I’m not easily sold on appearance alone. I need to know what’s behind the “pretty/handsome face.”  

I think where I am starting to look at the Mac over the PC is not for the aesthetic, or cult-like adherence by photographers, artists, and the like. Instead, I’m looking squarely at the stability of the underlying nuts-and-bolts. Principally, the operating system. This is what I want to understand more fully before making the leap. Is Apple’s OS just that much better than Windows? Or, is it a combination of the operating system and the hardware? (The question about the operating system is a bit rhetorical because not much research is needed to run across articles or reviews that effectively push Vista over a cliff.)

Though some may consider the design, look, and feel of the computer to be shallow; if you’re working on it daily, it is important. Given my penchant for minimalism (example: I subscribe to Dwell magazine), the Apple is perfect. However, I’ve not spent any time actually laying hands on the system. The tactile feel and response of the keyboard is very important to me. I type a lot–even more now that I’m blogging–and I need a comfortable and responsive keyboard. Considering all the bloggers I see banging out content on MacBooks, it suggests that the keyboard is good. I’ve read some reviews suggesting the keyboards on Macs are a little lacking, but I think there’s some subjectivity here because everyone has different typing styles. I’m a touch typist, so I may have a different perspective from someone who is a two-finger, hunt-and-peck typist. Moving to the physical product, I am not completely sold that Apple’s are the prettiest things out there. I’ve seen a number of laptops and desktops by Sony, Samsung and HP that rival, in my honest opinion, Apple’s aesthetic.

Turning the focus to the underlying system; this is an area where I want to be versed on facts not biases or hype. Whereas the look of the computer is rather subjective, the desire for a functioning operating system–free of mysterious alerts, bugs, viruses, etc., should be pretty objective. This is where I do tend to listen more attentively to Mac users, because what I universally hear is the satisfaction with the experience. Ask just about any PC user, and you’ll get a story, if not a tome, about problems. I seldom hear Mac owners saying, “God! This thing is a piece of sh*t!” If you could have been a fly on the wall last weekend, that would would have been the mildest expression uttered. Nevertheless, I don’t want to make a decision to change platforms in a knee jerk fashion; particularly when the switch to a Mac involves a pretty hefty investment. (I think Dave Cullen did a good job capturing the justification for the price differential between Macs and PCs in his video.) I would like to do a little more reading on the differences in operating systems. I would also appreciate, your comments. Whether objective or biased, it’s interesting to hear the perspective of people on both sides of the fence. I am particularly interested in hearing people who’ve tried both and why they made the decision to go with a PC or a Mac.

In fairness to my Toshiba; though there have been a few Vista  hiccups that have given me fits, I’ve had a pretty good experience with the laptop.  The programs that I have on the system work, and I’ve seldom encountered compatibility issues. From talking to friends, it appears that one of the major differences between the platforms is the ease of use for graphical design and layout. According to my fried Chris, iWeb would have cut the time redesigning my website in half, it not more. In fact, he e-mailed me the other day and said that had that been him dealing with all the freezing programs and convoluted graphic design; he would have  been standing at the door at the Apple store the next morning. I shared some of that emotion. I just don’t want to be hasty. Not to mention, I don’t have several thousand dollars to spend on completely new equipment. Hence, I am being rather deliberate about this issue, with the freedom of having a system that works, albeit not optimally.

Again, I’m interested to hear your opinion. If you were a PC user that made a switch to Mac, please share your experience. Would you go back to PC? If not, why? I am also very interested to hear from people who have tried Macs, but decided to stick with PCs.

  • Share/Bookmark

  • Note to Patrick: get a "mighty mouse" and right-click ability.
  • patrick carroll
    switched to mac book almost 2 years ago. it took a while to get used to, but no real regrets other than it doesnt have the right click -- you can work around, but it is the only thing i miss from my pc
  • I've got PCs at work (I'm an I.T. Director w/1,000 Windows users) and I live on Mac at home. I made the home-switch 3 yrs ago and never looked back.

    Pros
    Mac just works. Macs were slower in the PowerPC days when I started, but now on Intel core 2 duo etc, they are just as fast. I don't know any Mac users running AV, and I don't know any mac users infected by anything, EVER. I have PC friends with AV and anti-spyware that STILL get whacked (one just last week). With VmWare Fusion I can run XP and Linux virtual PCs on my Mac, can't beat that. I rarely run them though because I have everything I want in OS X.

    Photo apps (Lightroom, CS4, NX2, Aperture, Photomechanic, Capture One) all run on Mac. There are tons of utilities and free-ware out there for Mac. Tons. Lack of software is not an issue, don't let anyone fool you.

    Apple store: If there's one near you, you can get classes, repairs etc. Just walk in. Can't beat it.

    Vista was a disaster until Service Pak 2 and now, everyone is looking at Windows 7 (now in beta) and most businesses are bypassing Vista altogether. Windows 7 will be nice, so will Snow Leopard (next OS X version). You'd probably be happy with either one in the end, but I've never met someone using a Mac that regretted it. That won't change.

    Cons
    Still a computer, still runs on software, still has glitches. Rarely do I see OS level problems, most of the time it's an app that has a bug. It's no different than Windows in regards to apps bugs, but for the OS, I find it more reliable, in need of fewer reboots, and just keeps running. Of course, occasionally a patch will break the system because of some incompatibility or something. But it's rare and nothing like Windows patches/upgrades and the number of issues I see there. Yeah, someday people may write more Mac malware, but that could be 5 years away.... for now, live large on OS X and relax knowing it just works.

    Intangibles
    1) For some reason, and I'm not talented enough to express it properly, it just feels better sitting behind a Mac and working. Call it "user experience" call it "consistency" call it "design" or whatever. It's there.
    2) OS X is a flavor of Unix with a gorgeous GUI. At its core, Unix is a rock solid, enterprise level (e.g banks run on unix) kind of OS. Windows has come a long way in terms of reliability, but I believe one of the reasons for Macs rock solid performance is its Unix foundation.
    3) Cost. Macs suffer from no low-cost options except the Mini. The Mini is actually a great little box (I have one and I also have a Mac Pro), but you won't find $399 Mac Laptop specials anywhere. However, with Mac you save on AV and Spyware - costs which you must absorb w/ a PC. You save on movie/web/audio editing software (you get iPhoto, iWeb, iMovie and Garageband for free) and they are really decent programs. So, add their equivalents to the cost of a cheapo windows PC and the Mac premium is reduced. At the high end, the cost difference is minimal, but you're talking 4-core or 8-core boxes with multiple drive bays and 8GB to 16GB of RAM.

    Anyway, in the photography world, Mac has much, much higher utilization, probably closer to 50%, rather than the 9 or 10% overall, including all types of users. Good luck, don't sweat it, go Mac and don't look back....:-)
  • Peter, thanks for providing a nice pro/con perspective on the issue. It's truly appreciated.
blog comments powered by Disqus

<<

>>

my website

Matthew Lyons Photography

Theme Design by devolux.org

connect with me

Twitter  Facebook  Delicious  StumbleUpon  Digg  Picasa  Flickr  Blogger